Supervisors Will Propose New Limits on Nuisance Evictions
The board plans to unveil legislation this Tuesday to restrict grounds for eviction following a 41% spike in filings.
Updated on Oct. 5, 2026 in Apartments
Live Poll
Should your local government further restrict the legal grounds for evicting tenants?
Tenants in Lower Nob Hill and across San Francisco facing eviction notices may soon see stronger legal protections against nuisance-based removal. Supervisors Myrna Melgar and Jackie Fielder are set to introduce a proposal this Tuesday to redefine the criteria for these types of evictions.
Why it matters
As eviction filings topped 1,000 in 2026, the legislation aims to remove subjectivity from the city code to prevent residents from being displaced for minor infractions. It remains to be seen how the Board of Supervisors will balance these new tenant rights against property ownership interests.
The SF Rent Board recorded 405 nuisance eviction notices in 2026, a 41% increase over the 288 notices filed in the previous period. Total eviction filings citywide surpassed 1,000 for the year, with final figures on the impact of the proposed legal changes still unknown.
The players
Myrna Melgar
San Francisco Supervisor who is co-sponsoring legislation to change nuisance eviction laws.
Jackie Fielder
San Francisco Supervisor who is co-sponsoring the new limits on eviction grounds.
Daniel Lurie
The Mayor of San Francisco who declared a rent emergency amid the current rise in eviction filings.
Sue Yeng Yan
A 92-year-old tenant at 1120 Jackson St. who received an eviction notice in March 2026.
SF Rent Board
The city agency responsible for tracking rental disputes and issuing reports on eviction notice trends.
The details
The proposal requires that nuisance activity be severe, continuing, and recurring to justify an eviction, rather than subjective conditions. It also grants tenants the opportunity to pay for necessary repairs or cease alleged activity to resolve disputes before losing their housing. Supervisors plan to present the measure at this Tuesday's board meeting.
Timeline
1982: Sue Yeng Yan moved into 1120 Jackson St.
2025: Nabob Hill LLC purchased 1120 Jackson St.
February 2026: The SF Rent Board released its annual eviction report.
March 2026: Elderly tenants at the property received eviction notices.
June 2026: The landlord informed Yan that previous clutter conditions were cured.
Across the Bay
This proposal marks a significant shift from existing San Francisco rental law regarding nuisance evictions. By removing the word nuisance from the city code, the legislation seeks to move beyond the current definitions used by the Rent Board to govern landlord-tenant disputes.
If you are a tenant facing an eviction notice for nuisance, this legislation may provide a new legal path to resolve the claim by curing the issue or paying for repairs. Stay tuned for the Tuesday meeting to see how these potential changes could impact your specific rental agreement.
The takeaway
Tenants should track the upcoming legislative hearing to understand how these new criteria for nuisance-based eviction might affect their housing security. Monitor the Board of Supervisors schedule to see when public comment opens for this measure.
What happens next
The proposal will be unveiled at the Board of Supervisors meeting on Tuesday, October 9, 2026.
Further reading
For more information on current housing protections, visit the San Francisco Apartments section.
Live Poll
Should your local government further restrict the legal grounds for evicting tenants?
